Best on the Block 2025 Winners

Thirteen miles off the Rhode Island coast lies a jewel that rivals Martha’s Vineyard as New England’s quintessential summer escape. Block Island, with its dramatic bluffs, pristine beaches, and Victorian charm, continues to captivate visitors who make the scenic ferry journey to this enchanting isle. While the island boasts countless incredible restaurants, beaches, and attractions that make choosing favorites nearly impossible, after anonymous voting by peers on our website, we’re thrilled to present the “Best on the Block” award winners—celebrating the cream of the crop among Block Island’s exceptional destinations.
From the moment you step off the ferry into Old Harbor, with its gingerbread cottages and bustling waterfront, you know you’ve arrived somewhere special. These award winners represent the very best of what makes Block Island a cherished New England tradition.

A sign reads "Best on the Block Lobster Roll Ballard's Beach Resort Winner 2025" with a Block Island map outline, three gold stars above, and aerial view of an island in the background.

Best Lobster Roll: Ballard's Beach Resort

Nothing says New England summer like a perfectly crafted lobster roll enjoyed with sand between your toes and ocean waves as your soundtrack. Ballard’s Beach Resort takes the crown with their generous, buttery creation that embodies everything visitors dream of when they think of seaside dining. While Dead Eye Dick’s and The National also serve up memorable lobster rolls that keep locals and visitors coming back, Ballard’s oceanfront location and consistently excellent preparation make it the island’s lobster roll destination.

Award graphic featuring three gold stars, a map outline, and text reading: "Best on the Block Beach Mansion Beach Winner 2025." The background shows an aerial view of an island’s coastline.

Best Beach: Mansion Beach

With its expansive stretch of golden sand and stunning views, Mansion Beach offers the perfect blend of natural beauty and accessibility that defines the ideal Block Island beach experience. The gentle waves and spacious shoreline provide the quintessential New England beach day that rivals any coastal destination. Scotch Beach and Town Beach each have their devoted followers, but Mansion Beach’s combination of scenic beauty and family-friendly atmosphere makes it the island’s premier sandy paradise.

Award graphic with gold stars above an aerial island view. Text reads: “Best on the Block, Most Romantic Spot, The Atlantic Inn, Winner 2025” with a map outline and sponsorship note from getblockisland.com.

Most Romantic Spot: The Atlantic Inn

Perched majestically overlooking the island with sweeping ocean views, The Atlantic Inn creates an atmosphere of timeless elegance that has been enchanting couples for generations. The historic inn’s wraparound porches and sunset vistas provide the perfect backdrop for romantic moments that capture the essence of a New England coastal getaway. While Eli’s and The Lighthouse offer their own intimate charms, The Atlantic Inn’s combination of Victorian grandeur and panoramic beauty makes it Block Island’s most romantic destination.

A graphic with three gold stars above a sign reading "BEST ON THE BLOCK: Mudslide, Ballard’s Beach Resort WINNER 2025." Features a Block Island map silhouette and a faint aerial view of an island in the background.

Best Mudslide: Ballard's Beach Resort

When it comes to Block Island’s signature frozen cocktail, Ballard’s Beach Resort serves up the perfect blend of rich chocolate and coffee flavors that epitomizes summer relaxation. Their beachfront location means you can sip this indulgent treat while watching the waves roll in, creating the ultimate island moment. The Oar, Champlin’s, and Beach House all craft excellent mudslides, but Ballard’s consistently delivers the creamy, perfectly balanced cocktail that has become synonymous with Block Island summers.

Award graphic with gold stars above a sign reading "Best on the Block Coffee Aldo's Bakery Winner 2025" with a silhouette of Block Island and a website link at the bottom. Aerial view of Block Island in the background.

Best Coffee: Aldo's Bakery

Starting your Block Island morning with the rich, aromatic coffee from Aldo’s Bakery sets the perfect tone for a day of island exploration. This beloved local institution combines exceptional coffee with the warm, welcoming atmosphere that makes every visitor feel like a regular. While Persephone’s Kitchen and The Cracked Mug also brew excellent cups that fuel island adventures, Aldo’s Bakery’s perfect balance of quality coffee and authentic island charm makes it the morning destination of choice.

Award graphic with three gold stars and a map outline, reading: "Best on the Block Pizza Aldo's Restaurant Winner 2025," with "Sponsored by getblockisland.com" at the bottom. Background shows an aerial coastal view.

Best Pizza: Aldo's Restaurant

When island appetites call for comfort food done right, Aldo’s Restaurant delivers with pizzas that combine fresh ingredients with the kind of perfection that comes from years of island tradition. Their crispy crusts and perfectly balanced toppings create the satisfying meal that caps off perfect beach days. Poor People’s Pub and Block Island Pizza Truck both serve up crowd-pleasing pies, but Aldo’s Restaurant’s consistent quality and welcoming atmosphere make it the island’s pizza champion.

A graphic with gold stars above a sign reading: "Best on the Block—Bachelorette/Bachelor Destination, Ballard's Beach Resort, Winner 2025," with a Block Island map silhouette and an ocean aerial view in the background.

Best Bachelor/Bachelorette Destination: Ballard's Beach Resort

For celebration groups seeking the perfect blend of beachfront fun and party atmosphere, Ballard’s Beach Resort offers everything needed for an unforgettable pre-wedding celebration. The combination of oceanfront location, lively bar scene, and accommodating staff creates the ideal setting for creating lasting memories with your closest friends. Block Island Beach House and Spring House Hotel both provide excellent group experiences, but Ballard’s unique beachfront party atmosphere makes it the ultimate celebration destination.

An award badge reading "Best on the Block Hiking Spot: Mohegan Bluffs & Lighthouse Winner 2025," with gold stars above and an island map, over a faint aerial background of a coastline.

Best Hiking Spot: Mohegan Bluffs & Southeast Lighthouse

Standing atop the dramatic 200-foot Mohegan Bluffs with the iconic Southeast Lighthouse as your backdrop creates one of New England’s most breathtaking hiking experiences. The wooden stairs leading down to the secluded beach below and the panoramic ocean views rival any coastal destination for natural beauty and Instagram-worthy moments. While Clay Head Nature Trail and Block Island Greenway offer their own scenic adventures, the combination of Mohegan Bluffs and Southeast Lighthouse provides the quintessential Block Island hiking experience that showcases the island’s dramatic natural beauty.

A graphic with gold stars above a "Best on the Block" 2025 winner plaque for Poor People's Pub, recognized as a dog-friendly spot, set against an aerial view of an island.

Most Dog-Friendly Spot: The Beachhead

Island adventures are always better with your four-legged family members, and The Beachhead welcomes both you and your furry companions with open arms. Their accommodating atmosphere and dog-friendly policies make it easy to include your pets in the Block Island experience. Poor People’s Pub and Ballard’s also roll out the welcome mat for well-behaved dogs, but The Beachhead’s consistently pet-friendly approach makes it the top choice for visitors traveling with their beloved companions.

A graphic shows three gold stars above an aerial view of an island. Overlaid, a bold black and white box reads: "Best on the Block Winner—Most Instagrammable Spot: Southeast Lighthouse. 2025. Sponsored by getblockisland.com.

Most Instagrammable Spot: Southeast Lighthouse

No Block Island visit is complete without capturing the iconic Southeast Lighthouse, whose red brick tower and stunning clifftop location create the perfect New England postcard moment. The lighthouse’s dramatic setting atop Mohegan Bluffs provides endless photo opportunities that showcase the island’s natural beauty and maritime heritage. While the Giant Adirondack Chair and Clay Head offer their own photogenic charms, Southeast Lighthouse remains the island’s most recognizable and Instagram-worthy landmark that captures the essence of this special place.

These award winners represent the heart and soul of what makes Block Island a treasured New England destination. From the moment the ferry pulls away from the mainland to your last sunset view, Block Island offers experiences that create lifelong memories. Whether you’re seeking adventure, romance, relaxation, or celebration, these “Best on the Block” destinations ensure your island escape will be everything you dreamed of and more.

Skip to content