When it comes to choosing the ultimate island getaway in the Northeast, two destinations tend to top the list: Block Island, Rhode Island, and Montauk, New York. Each offers its own unique charm, stunning coastline, and breezy summer lifestyle. But if you’re wondering which island oasis to try next, we’re here to compare the two on everything from atmosphere and accessibility to food, beaches, and overall vibe.
Let’s start with Block Island. Just a ferry ride from the Rhode Island mainland, Block Island feels like a step back in time. With its preserved Victorian architecture, undeveloped coastline, and cozy small-town pace, the island draws visitors seeking tranquility, natural beauty, and a sense of escape. There’s a romanticism here that appeals to travelers looking to unplug. Biking is popular, the pace is slow, and the views—especially from Mohegan Bluffs—are dramatic and unforgettable.
Dining on Block Island is surprisingly diverse, especially for its size. Beachfront dining at Ballard’s Beach Resort offers a seamless blend of luxury and laid-back ambiance. Lounge in the sun with full-service dining right on the sand, while savoring fresh seafood and craft cocktails. There’s live music, tiki bars, and a sense that you’ve found your own little pocket of paradise.
By contrast, Montauk—sitting at the eastern tip of Long Island—is better known for its buzz. Once a quiet fishing village, it’s now a hotspot for stylish weekenders from NYC, social media influencers, and celebrities seeking coastal cool. Expect boutique hotels, bustling nightlife, and a scene that’s both trendy and fast-paced. The Hamptons vibe spills over into Montauk, which can make it feel exclusive but also a bit less relaxed for those wanting a true wind-down.
Montauk’s beaches are wide and beautiful, and there’s no shortage of stylish places to eat, drink, and be seen. But with popularity comes crowds, and reservations are often required well in advance. It’s a destination built for the extroverted traveler—the one who loves a sunset rooftop cocktail followed by a seafood dinner and late-night dancing.
When it comes to accessibility, Montauk is reachable by train, car, or bus from New York City, making it an easy option for a last-minute weekend getaway. Block Island, while a bit more of a journey, rewards travelers with a slower, quieter pace and that elusive feeling of being far away—without going too far as you need to take a ferry to get there.
So which island oasis should you choose? If you’re craving serenity, barefoot luxury, and the kind of summer experience where time stretches long and the days end with beachside dinners and firelight, Block Island is calling. But if you want to dive into a scene full of energy, stylish crowds, and nonstop action, Montauk might be your perfect match.
Ultimately, both destinations are stunning in their own way. It’s simply a matter of choosing your version of paradise. And who says you can’t try both?
