Block Island isn’t just a summer escape; it’s a destination for those in pursuit of unforgettable fine dining. Amidst its windswept beaches and quaint town center lies a food scene that offers something truly special: restaurants that bring the island’s local ingredients to life in dishes as memorable as the views. This isn’t simply a meal; it’s a bucket-list experience for the discerning traveler, where each plate tells a story of coastal charm and fresh flavors.
From celebrated seafood to inventive American cuisine, Block Island’s fine dining venues create an atmosphere where every detail feels like a luxury. Perfect for celebrating life’s big moments—or for creating one—these dining experiences are the highlights of any Block Island itinerary. Come for the scenery, stay for the unforgettable flavors, and toast to an evening that feels effortlessly elegant, uniquely Block Island
1. The 1661 Inn Restaurant: A Feast with a View
Nestled along Spring Street, The 1661 Inn Restaurant is a destination for diners seeking an exquisite pairing of refined cuisine and coastal views. Here, New England’s finest ingredients meet culinary artistry, offering a range of dishes that celebrate the region’s rich flavors.
Atmosphere & Vibe: Step into the 1661, and you’re greeted by an elegant, beach-chic ambiance that radiates calm sophistication. Every detail, from the crisp white linens to the artful table settings, enhances the experience of dining by the water. Whether seated indoors or on the terrace, the views over Block Island Sound provide the perfect backdrop for a serene, memorable meal.
Must-Do: Time your dinner around sunset to watch the golden glow over the Sound as you savor the meal. With its attentive service and curated wine list, The 1661 Inn is the perfect spot for a celebratory evening or intimate date night.
2. Winfield’s: A Worldly Experience with a Block Island Fine Dining Twist
Tucked away on Corn Neck Road, Winfield’s brings global flavors to Block Island, blending French, Italian, New American, and Asian influences into a dining experience that feels cozy yet worldly. Known for its candle-lit ambiance and eclectic menu, Winfield’s is a favorite for food lovers looking for a sophisticated yet intimate spot.
Dining Experience: Winfield’s embraces a warm, intimate setting where every table feels private. Soft lighting, rustic charm, and an understated elegance give the dining room a calm, welcoming atmosphere. This is the kind of place where you can enjoy a slow, intentional meal without distractions.
Need to Know: Winfield’s is popular among locals and visitors alike, so reservations are recommended. The dining room’s serene atmosphere makes it a great choice for those looking to enjoy an unhurried evening, and only guests over 12 years old are allowed, preserving its refined atmosphere.
3. Spring House Hotel: Classic Block Island Fine Dining
Set atop a gentle hill on Spring Street, the Spring House Hotel boasts one of the most breathtaking dining locations on the island. This historic hotel is more than just a place to stay—it’s home to a restaurant that blends coastal elegance with the unmistakable flavors of New England. For those looking to pair gourmet dining with panoramic ocean views, this is the place to be.
The Setting: The restaurant’s Victorian architecture, with wide porches and wraparound balconies, gives it a sense of timeless charm. The outdoor seating area offers sweeping ocean views that feel worlds away, making it a dream setting for a romantic dinner or gathering with friends.
Why It’s Special: Spring House Hotel also hosts seasonal events, from intimate wine tastings to chef’s dinners, making it a culinary hub on Block Island. With impeccable service, a world-class wine list, and the kind of warmth that feels like home, a meal here feels like a little piece of paradise.
End Your Block Island Fine Dining Experience in Style
Fine dining on Block Island offers a unique blend of elegance, creativity, and local flair. Each of these restaurants transforms fresh, local ingredients into memorable dishes, capturing the spirit of the island in every bite. Whether it’s the elevated charm of The 1661 Inn, the eclectic style of Winfield’s, or the breathtaking views at the Spring House Hotel, Block Island’s fine dining spots promise an experience that will linger long after the last course is served.
