Best Seafood on Block Island – Must-Try Places for Fresh Coastal Flavor
There’s nothing quite like seafood in New England, and Block Island is no exception. With the Atlantic at its doorstep, this little slice of paradise is home to some of the freshest, most mouthwatering seafood you’ll find anywhere. Whether you’re craving a buttery lobster roll, a classic clam chowder, or freshly shucked oysters, these must-try spots serve up the best seafood on Block Island that you simply can’t miss.
1. Finn’s Seafood
A staple of Block Island dining, Finn’s Seafood has been serving up the best seafood on Block Island for years. Known for their fried clams, fish and chips, and legendary lobster rolls, this spot is perfect for a casual meal with a side of ocean breeze.
2. Dead Eye Dick’s
If you’re looking for a spot with incredible seafood and a killer view, Dead Eye Dick’s is a must. Their seared tuna and clam cakes are local favorites, making it one of the best seafood on Block Island destinations for a laid-back yet unforgettable meal.
3. Eli’s Restaurant
A hidden gem on the island, Eli’s offers a cozy, upscale dining experience with an emphasis on fresh ingredients. Their seafood specials change daily, but you can always count on getting some of the most delicious seafood on Block Island, whether it’s pan-seared scallops or a delicate seafood risotto.
4. The Beachead
Steps from the sand, The Beachead is the kind of place where you can sit back with a cold drink and enjoy seafood on Block Island while listening to the waves roll in. Their lobster BLT and seafood chowder are local legends.
5. Kimberly’s
Kimberly’s is known for its warm, welcoming vibe and seriously delicious seafood dishes. The blackened tuna and scallop pasta keep visitors coming back, and it’s one of the best spots for a memorable seafood dinner.
6. Ballard’s
A beachfront institution, Ballard’s isn’t just about the lively atmosphere—it’s also home to some amazing seafood on Block Island. Fresh oysters, lobster, and grilled swordfish are just a few highlights on their extensive menu.
7. Poor People’s Pub
Don’t let the name fool you—this spot delivers big on flavor and fresh seafood. Their fish tacos and stuffed quahogs are a must-try, making it one of the top spots for seafood on Block Island in a fun and casual setting.
8. Payne’s Dock
Known for their famous “Killer Donuts,” Payne’s Dock also serves up some of the freshest seafood around. Their clam chowder and stuffed lobster are island favorites, and the laid-back dockside vibe makes it a great stop after a day on the water.
9. The Surf Hotel Restaurant
Dining at The Surf Hotel is a true New England experience. With sweeping ocean views and a menu stacked with the seafood on Block Island, it’s the perfect place to enjoy everything from baked stuffed lobster to a classic New England seafood boil.
10. The National Hotel Dining Room
For a classic, upscale seafood experience, The National Hotel’s dining room is the place to be. Their fresh Block Island oysters and buttery lobster tails make it one of the top choices for seafood on Block Island with a touch of elegance.
Savor the Best Seafood on Block Island
From casual dockside shacks to elegant seaside dining, the seafood on Block Island is always fresh, always flavorful, and always worth the trip. Whether you’re here for the day or making a weekend of it, be sure to indulge in some of the island’s finest seafood—you won’t regret it!
