Block Island may be small, but it’s brimming with dining spots that offer the perfect blend of laid-back island vibes and unforgettable flavors. Casual dining on Block Island isn’t just about grabbing a bite; it’s about savoring meals with a view, enjoying fresh, local ingredients, and experiencing the true charm of this seaside haven. If you’re planning a visit, here are three must-try casual spots that serve up a memorable taste of Block Island—no reservations or dress codes required.
1. Ballard’s Beach Resort: The Ultimate Beachside Experience
At Ballard’s Beach Resort, dining feels like a mini escape to paradise. Located just steps from the ferry dock, Ballard’s offers a true Block Island experience: sand between your toes, ocean views in every direction, and a menu that speaks to classic New England flavors with a tropical twist. This is the place to be if you want to soak up the island vibe with good food and a great atmosphere.
What’s on the Menu
Ballard’s menu has something for everyone, from seafood staples to casual favorites. Their Lobster Rolls are a standout, packed with sweet, fresh lobster and served on a toasted roll with a side of beachy bliss. For those in the mood for something a bit heartier, the Beach Burger, features as the picture of this post! It delivers big flavor with all the fixings, while the Fish Tacos offer a lighter option, filled with grilled local fish, fresh slaw, and a hint of citrus.
Why You’ll Love It
The ambiance at Ballard’s is unbeatable. Live music fills the air, ocean waves create the perfect background noise, and the beach is open to all for swimming and lounging. Order a signature cocktail (the tropical “Ballard’s Breeze” is a favorite) and sink into a beach chair after your meal. Ballard’s makes every meal feel like a celebration, and it’s an essential stop for anyone visiting Block Island.
2. Dead Eye Dick’s: A Harbor Gem with Nautical Charm
Set along New Harbor, Dead Eye Dick’s is a Block Island favorite that combines classic seafood with a relaxed, nautical setting. It’s a spot where boaters dock for a fresh meal, locals come to catch up, and visitors indulge in some of the best seafood on the island. The vibe here is effortlessly casual, with a touch of salty-sea charm that makes it ideal for a laid-back lunch or dinner.
What’s on the Menu
Dead Eye Dick’s is known for its Stuffed Quahogs—a Rhode Island specialty that features clams stuffed with breadcrumbs, spices, and a hint of bacon. It’s a starter you won’t want to miss. The Swordfish Sandwich also shines, grilled to perfection and served with a house-made aioli on a soft bun. For those craving something lighter, the New Harbor Salad with fresh greens, local seafood, and a zesty vinaigrette provides a refreshing option.
Why You’ll Love It
Dining at Dead Eye Dick’s feels like an authentic taste of Block Island. The harbor views, warm hospitality, and perfectly prepared seafood capture the essence of island life. With patio seating that overlooks the water, it’s the kind of place where you can kick back, savor your meal, and take in the island’s relaxed pace. And if you’re lucky, you might catch a stunning sunset over the harbor as you dine.
3. Poor People’s Pub: Good Food, Good Vibes, No Fuss
Don’t let the name fool you—Poor People’s Pub is one of Block Island’s most beloved casual dining spots. Located in the heart of town, this pub combines classic comfort food with a fun, lively atmosphere. It’s the kind of place where friends gather, families dig in, and everyone feels welcome. With its mix of playful decor and a menu packed with favorites, Poor People’s Pub brings a taste of Block Island’s fun-loving spirit.
What’s on the Menu
Poor People’s Pub is famous for its Pulled Pork Nachos—a piled-high plate of crispy chips topped with pulled pork, cheese, and fresh jalapeños, perfect for sharing. Their Fried Clams are a New England classic done right, crispy on the outside and tender inside. If you’re in the mood for a sandwich, the Big Kahuna Burger doesn’t disappoint, stacked with toppings and served with a side of crispy fries.
Why You’ll Love It
With its laid-back vibe, friendly service, and hearty portions, Poor People’s Pub is a go-to for casual dining. It’s the kind of place where you can come as you are, unwind with friends, and enjoy a meal that hits all the right spots. Whether you’re grabbing lunch before heading back to the beach or finishing up a day of exploring the island, Poor People’s Pub is always a good idea.
Embrace the Casual Side of Block Island Dining
Block Island’s casual dining spots offer more than just delicious food—they deliver the island’s unmistakable charm, a sense of relaxation, and an invitation to enjoy each moment. Whether you’re kicking back at Ballard’s Beach Resort, savoring fresh seafood at Dead Eye Dick’s, or digging into comfort food at Poor People’s Pub, these restaurants capture the essence of Block Island. So, come hungry, grab a seat with a view, and experience the flavors that make Block Island feel like home.
